Establish which material each laboratory received
Assign a parent sample identifier and record the code given to each dispatched portion. Keep the receiving laboratory’s acknowledgement with the supplier lot record. If one report refers to a retained sample and another to a recent shipment, ask how each sample was obtained. A comparison can be technically precise while still answering different questions about material identity, so settle that link before interpreting results.


Align the definitions used in both reports
Write the reported characteristic from each document in its own words and compare the units, method version and any stated limits. ICH Q2(R2) discusses intended use when assessing analytical procedures. For a purchasing decision, ask the laboratories whether the two results can be directly compared for the agreed characteristic. Record a difference in reporting basis separately from a difference in the measured result.
Respond to mismatched conclusions with a defined question
If two analyses of the proposed lot yield differing main-peak percentages, first compare the named samples and definitions of the total integrated signal. Ask each laboratory to identify the evidence underlying its conclusion and any limitations it has noted. Give both reviewers the same question and preserve both original reports. Purchasing can then decide whether a clarification resolves the issue or whether additional evidence from a clearly identified sample is warranted.
Worked example
If two laboratories present the same sample under different accession numbers, request both accession acknowledgements and the buyer’s dispatch record. Establish the documented chain between their submissions before comparing reported values. Keep any remaining difference in sample origin visible in the summary.
Prepare your inquiry
Confirm the sample relationship and measurement basis before comparing conclusions.